In shocking news Barry Trotz is reportedly stepping down as GM of the Preds once they find a replacement. It’s not necessarily shocking that Trotz won’t be GM in the 2026-27 season, it’s that this announcement is made about a month prior to the trade deadline in which the Preds are likely to be an active team.
Trotz’s tenure as GM has been a weird one where the Preds have tried to rebuild on the fly in a sport where that’s almost impossible. In the NHL you have to be all in (chasing a cup) or all out (tanking). I get the hesitation to tank because it doesn’t guarantee you a cup but looking at the top players in the league, they are almost all are top 3 draft picks in the draft, somewhere the Preds have drafted only once in their history and that was inaugural draft for the team in 1998.
A brief timeline of the Trotz Era: February 2023 named the replacement for the retiring David Poile, highlight of the 2023-24 season was the magical run after they canceled a trip to the Sphere to watch U2 that gave Trotz some false hope that a full rebuild wasn’t necessary, went all in during the summer of 2024, disastrous 2024-25 season, and the 2025-26 season that has been better than last season but a team that is more likely to have a top 5 pick than be a cup contender.
I hope everything is ok with Trotz and his family and that isn’t leading to this decision but from a hockey standpoint being at a crossroads of needing to blow it up and rebuild stronger is the likely reason for his decision to step down at this time. There are a handful of expiring contracts that there shouldn’t be any hesitation to move for picks/prospects, then you have the 2024 Free Agent class that ultimately hasn’t delivered what Trotz had hoped and either the deadline or this summer something needs to be done with those contracts, and lastly you have Josi, Forsberg, and Saros where someone needs to have a conversation on do they want to ride out the rebuild or chase a cup.
The bright spot for the Trotz era has been his draft picks specifically in the 1st round. Matthew Wood, Tanner Molendyk, Yegor Surin, Brady Martin, Cameron Reid, and Ryker Lee are all looking like players that will contribute for the Preds in the future so in one way you can say that Trotz has left the franchise in better shape than it was when he took over as GM, but on the other hand the last 3 years feel like a wasted 3 years that could have been better utilized to rebuild than being a pretender delaying the inevitable.
What’s next for the Preds? Finding a GM with experience with a rebuild would be a good place to start. The Preds GM history is Poile from 1998-2023 and Trotz 2023-present, that’s it. It’s time to go outside the Preds tree and make an outside hire that brings a new perspective and embraces the much needed rebuild. That would likely be followed by a new HC and a bunch of trades. Things will likely get worse before they get better but if they are able to bottom out and add a couple high end prospects it could completely reshape the future of the franchise which should be the end game with this change at GM.